in the deep fog - III

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• sevy (7032)
• [2008-10-02 5:47]

Bonjour Catherine,

Superbe cette ambiance qui est bien montrée par le cadrage et surtout les 3 personnes en premier plan qui habillent et habitent cette scene.
Bon, effectivement il y a du bruit, et ca limitera l emploi de cette photo a des petits formats, mais ca ne m empeche pas de bien aimé.

Yves.

•  
• pcp (3087)
• [2008-10-02 5:49]

Hi Cath,

Wonderful shot and great composition with lovely fog. Excellant shot.. waiting for my time ;)

Well done.

TFS

Senthil

•  
• lestans (12986)
• [2008-10-02 6:01]

Ciao Cath! E' una bella scena, con tanta luce, e mi piace l'atteggiamento dei tre personaggi. Forse i colori a destra sono un po' strani.
Ciao!!!
Livia

•      
• battousai (786)
• [2008-10-02 6:13]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

Hey Cath,

I think this is a wonderful picture with a lot of potential. I'm saying potential because I think you didn't go to your limits with post production here. It looks very nice in colour yet you forgot about reducing the colour grain just a bit. In my opinion it would help a lot and give the picture much more softer look.

I'm mostly a B&W person that's why I've tried to do a workshop of this picture in a B&W manner. I hope you like it.

Best

Pawel

•  
• dvlazar (4805)
• [2008-10-02 6:17]

Fantastic fog photo. The imagary of the 3 people walking away into it is just perfect - it's very India and captures the essence of this region. A beauty slice of life!
Dave

•  
• zmey (5540)
• [2008-10-02 7:39]
• [+]

hello catherine
beautiful morning mood here... i like that gracious mother's figure folloewed by her son. the tree silhouette lies very comfortably in your composition too. as to the workshop: i tend to disagree... enhancing contrasts (that's what curves adjustment seems to have done) on a foggy/misty shot loses the essence of displaying FOG... also, i like that slight reminder of blue (goes well with the misty morning mood) in her sari but i agree, the hint of the road color in the right corner could be lost. otherwise, the WS seems just plain harsher to me: and I do not see why that harshness would be needed in this scene.

warm regards,
kristaps

•  
• MarcT (16390)
• [2008-10-02 8:56]

Salut Catherine,
Superbe image prise au bon moment. La petite famille s'enfonce dans ce brouillard qui cache tout.
Bien vu
Marc

•  
• Silvio1953 (27510)
• [2008-10-02 12:14]

Ciao Caterina, affascinante composizione di famiglia resa magica dalla nebbia, brava, ciao Silvio

•  
• jonathan_hart (17069)
• [2008-10-02 13:37]

le cadrage est impeccable, rien à redire, bon timing, avec cette visibilité qui se réduit peu à peu, une ambiance superbe se dégage de cette photo
amicalement
jc

•  
• serkan_senturk (188)
• [2008-10-02 13:40]

slm catherine çok hoş bir çalışma eline sağlık çok güzel bir kadrajı ve atmosfer, var

•  
• photographer123 (4514)
• [2008-10-03 9:11]

hi..
Very good shot..atmosphere made the shot mystic..very well done...subir

•  
• Polonaise (18025)
• [2008-10-03 14:07]

I may say - the same story applies to this cutie...
There are so many of them from India, it's only natural to slightly shrug your shoulders...
Yet...
It's good, Cathy.
This stuff is ALWAYS good :-)))

george

....

•      
• Burberry1 (6025)
• [2008-10-03 14:10]

This is a masterpiece among masterpieces!!!!!
An unique scene in the unique mood!
I love it Catherine!!!

My best regards, Agnieszka

•  
• horatiuTT (4312)
• [2008-10-04 10:16]

Hi Cath,
quite a magnificent achievement this photo,
being there as a great observer and using this
fantastic whether conditions,very flawless presentation and super body language of the persons,a great prove that great photos can be made without being a maniac of the expansive photographic equipment.
Kind regards,
Horatiu

•  
• ChrisJ (57444)
• [2008-10-04 20:21]

Hi Catherine

A very under rated shot with lots of mood & atmosphere from the fog & mist. The 2 people add a nice human element, & I like the muted graphism. Merci et bon weekend!

•  
• salvator (17443)
• [2008-10-10 2:00]

Bonjour Catherine,
Wooow this is superb. The misty background, the wonderfully defined silouettes, and the colorful woman and child walking make this a prize winner. Simply wonderful.
Je vous shouaite un excellent weekend. Amities. Salvator.

•  
• rtg (15)
• [2008-10-23 1:10]

Hey nice pic! the mother, kids pair being enhanced and the soft quality of the backgournd gives it a very pleasant feel... i can actually experience the cold,foggy morning... :) nice effect on the whole.