YES!

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• toni_al (14358)
• [2005-05-10 15:48]

Bonsoir Gal
YES superbe cadrage, pour ces courageux des émotions fortes. Le tout sous des tons gris, qu'est ce que cela donne en N&B ?
Salutations
Toni

•  
• AmiBe (19514)
• [2005-05-10 16:07]

Yes, I am (a variant) !

C'est cool, le silver star !
J'aime bien ce cadrage et ce bras qui se lève...
C'est très graphique.

•  
• Tavo (586)
• [2005-05-10 18:41]

It’s fine when a note doesn’t match fully with a picture, when it doesn’t explain picture and picture is not an illustration of the note. It provokes further thoughts. For instance: I am not convinced that a single fist raised up against empty space during the childish mass entertainment is a sign of variant individuality, and I don’t see it as a gesture of system evolving factor. But I also can relax from my "ratio" and thanks to the quality of your picture and writing to feel and believe in this game adn enjoy it. Maybe I am not so desperate game-quitter, although it’s too late for me to become a true variant. May I stay somewhere between?
In your free fabulation of ideas I recognise some mental kinship with Jorrit, not crazy though.
PeterB

•  
• flydragon (0)
• [2005-05-10 18:58]

hello Gal
c'est gris et c'est beau
j'aime bcp cette composition
mm apres un peu voir meme trop d'absence sur TE
je découvre de superbes photos ;o)
bien vue cette photo.
va falloir que je fasse un tour voir les photo d'Asie ;o)
A + Gal
••simon••

•  
• athos99 (6884)
• [2005-05-11 2:57]

Salut Gal

Je trouve que la composition est très soignée. La dominante du gris avec les petites tâches de couleurs des bras des passagers donne de la force à cette image.
J’aime aussi le côté graphique et comme tu as mis en valeur cette machine.

•  
• Rinie_Hoff (9316)
• [2005-05-11 9:38]

Bonjour Gal, very, very strong composition, curves, straight lines, triangles, and that one arm standing out, is enough for you to write a good, thorough note. I remember one of the discussions I think in the 'photography' forum about being an individual, that everyone would like to be one, but who really is? (or something like that, I don't remember excatly, but I think your name popped up there, of course ;-)).
I have been in such a thing once, was always a bit afraid, but then I thought, that it was probably safer that the usual traffic, and I plunged in. I loved it! But one of the nicest things about it, that I finally got the chance to use my singing technique to the full, and scream as loud as I could, which is very loud (everyone gets deaf, when I do that). Not because I was afraid, I wasn't, but just for the joy to use my voice at the maximum volume.
You will certainly think that I am even younger than you at first assumed, but now also probably think that I'm rather immature as well, so be it. ;-)

•  
• Isabelle (7778)
• [2005-05-11 13:05]

the image is disturbing... i mean, i would expect movement and you show stillness.
as for your note... well, living here is not for beginners.

•  
• RandomCameraGuy (3046)
• [2005-05-11 21:50]

Interesting note (though I agree with Peter, Tavo, that it's a bit of a tangent from the pic) and the pic is much better than I thought from the thumb (where I didn't make out the raised fists). My main critique here is that though the composition of elements is good, the colour is really kindof dull. I thought about BW, but then the little splashes of colour would be missing, so I'm left thinking that things could be better, but am unsure of how to improve the source matierial.

Ahh well. ;)

It's still a nice shot Gal.

alex

•  
• tongapup (1574)
• [2005-05-12 17:25]

I can't help it, I just love your tangential rants. Don't we all wish we were variants? Well, I'm pretty certain you are.

Nice photo, good moment. I somewhat agree with Alex on the colour issue but what can you do?

•  
• kourosh (2356)
• [2005-05-13 3:33]

Hey Gal, what a cool shot. I like the geometry of the bars and pillars and of course the YES!

•  
• gringofil (0)
• [2005-05-14 9:16]

Nice moment here, Gal, with the arm in the air and monsoon type clouds for background. Not sure why some say the colors are not as great as they would want them to be...for me they work just fine. Quite a different shot for you but in more ways than one an original image. Well done.

•  
• dolin (15647)
• [2005-05-25 5:10]

Salut Gal.
Sympa et originale cette compo.
C'est assez graphique et dynamique.
J'aime bien ce peu de couleurs et ces lignes qui partent dans plusieurs directions.
Belle prise de vue.
Bien vu.
Fred

•  
• Haymotion (1655)
• [2005-05-25 5:30]

Jolie composition !!
Angle de vue très original et qualité de la photo parfaite !!
Bravo
J'aime bien également tous les différents gris qui compos ta photo
Beau travail
Vince

•  
• naxius (16675)
• [2005-05-25 9:41]

Bonjour Gal,
Superbe cette photo. Ce que j'aime le plus c'est bien evidemment ce bras qui sort des rangs, qui ne respecte pas l'ordre etablit qui est de subir en criant sans bouger la force de ce manege.
C'est bien vu, j'adore!!
Alex

•  
• cmartos (6086)
• [2005-05-31 9:46]

A dire vrai Gal, je n'en sais rien, rien du tout. Sur que les fouteurs de M font la vie, car la vie sans evolution ni changement c'est la mort. Je n'aurais pas choisi cette image pour ce propos, bien que l'on voit un de ces fouteurs de M lever le bras. L'image est un peu sombre a mon gout. Mais le sujet est bon, le cadrage me plait egalement, bien que le tout manque un peu de Gal.

A+

•      
• Suh (10)
• [2005-07-15 15:45]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• manny (21378)
• [2005-07-27 1:23]

I like the graphism. Nice framing. And look at tose hands. Seemed like choreographed. Great catch.

•  
• andante (6652)
• [2006-01-10 23:03]

Gal, this is great by every standard, thanks for sharing!!