Dreaming A Big Fish

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• wilkinsonsg (8502)
• [2004-12-12 5:14]

Very good almost'graphic' B&W image.
The fisherman's rods make a nice repeating line to follow and the pebbles on the beach add to the patterns created by the sea :)

•  
• jp80 (8427)
• [2004-12-12 6:31]

Very beautiful one. Nice tones, goos crop and movement with this man walking. The sharpness is good too. I like !

Pascal

•  
• clodreno (0)
• [2004-12-12 7:43]

Very nice shot.. You really composed it nicely. Your choice of Black and white is also very appropriate for this one.
Very graphic.. Love it.

•  
• faraujo (1268)
• [2004-12-12 16:53]

atmosfera perfeita... o B&W realça os ambientes de trabalho.

Humm!!! Deve estar frio...
Boas fotos

•  
• nwoehnl (60383)
• [2004-12-12 17:53]

Good beach scene, Robert. The fishing rods stiking up establish a good rhythmic quality, and the fisherman as well as their gear placed on this piece of land look really good in the b&w presentation and with the strong contrast which seems to enhance the feeling of "ruggedness" (in case that's a word). Well done on this one.

•  
• pamastro (7209)
• [2004-12-13 0:55]

The black and white suits this scene well. The rocks give the ground a grainy, hard, texture that I think is enhanced by this treatment. Even the sea comes off as hard and cold. And so it's quite a contrast to see a person sleeping on this rough surface. I like how the other fisherman is also sleeping in his chair. This leaves the one awake to tend all three it seems as he walks between them. It's nicely done and well captured with the poles rising above the horizon.

•  
• russte (0)
• [2006-04-20 11:48]

Robert, I like this one very much as well but perhaps there are just too many elements in the composition. The strength lies in the fishermen but the eye is drawn away from them to the person lying on the beach. Nice try. Stephen